South Otselic, New York

Quality Cars. Hometown Values.

A friendly conversation. A straightforward car search. Your next chapter starts here on the hill.

Illustrated landscape and vehicles

Friendly, personal attention

Pre-owned vehicles

Straightforward conversations

Here in our community

Illustrative Bill on the Hill Auto Sales sign beside a country road; not a photograph of the dealership

Your neighbors in South Otselic

Welcome to Bill on the Hill

At Bill on the Hill Auto Sales, we believe finding your next vehicle should feel straightforward and personal. Browse the details, ask your questions, and stop by to see us in South Otselic. We’re here to help you find the right fit.

13 available now

Browse our current pre-owned inventory

See something you like? Give us a call with your questions or arrange a time to take a look.

Your next vehicle

Make room for what comes next

Tell us about your trade-in or ask a question about your next vehicle.

Have a vehicle to trade?

Tell us what you’re driving and what you’re looking for. Call us or send us your vehicle’s details and a few photos.

Trade-In Options

Financing information

Contact your preferred lender about financing, and ask us about the vehicle you have in mind.

Learn About Financing

Visit or call

Location & hours

775 Stage Road
South Otselic, NY 13155
Sunday
Closed
Monday
8 AM–4 PM
Tuesday
8 AM–4 PM
Wednesday
8 AM–4 PM
Thursday
8 AM–4 PM
Friday
8 AM–4 PM
Saturday
Closed